Collectively Speaking

Season 2: Episode 5 - Tech and AI in Community Engagement (Festive Special!)

β€’ Max Farrell β€’ Season 2 β€’ Episode 5

For the 5th episode in the second series of LDN Collective podcasts, tackling the big issues in the built environment, we decided to LEAP outside our comfort zone! πŸš€ 

 πŸ€– Recorded live at our recent event exploring the impact of technology and AI on community engagement, we started with an open mic session where all 50 attendees had the opportunity to share their stories. 

 πŸ“š This was followed by presentations from pioneers like ECF, Commonplace, Digital Urban, Hello Lamp Post, Concept Culture and Grosvenor. We finished with a lively panel discussion and there was a LOT of food for thought.

Hopefully see you at our next event in the New Year, likely to focus on community engagement and regional planning. Our January podcast will be on Net Zero Neighbourhoods with Hannah Jewkes πŸŽ‰ 

Find out more about the LDN Collective at
https://ldn-collective.com/

<b>[Music]</b><b>Welcome everybody to</b><b>this very special</b><b>edition of</b><b>Collectively Speaking.</b><b>This is a bit</b><b>different in that we</b><b>are going to hear lots</b><b>of voices today.</b><b>We're here at the</b><b>Seven Dials Club in</b><b>Covent Garden and lots</b><b>of really</b><b>interesting guests</b><b>and speakers at an</b><b>event which is going</b><b>to look at the</b><b>evolving nature of</b><b>community engagement</b><b>and particularly the</b><b>role of technology and</b><b>artificial</b><b>intelligence and how</b><b>that's starting</b><b>to change things for</b><b>better or for worse</b><b>and that's one of the</b><b>things we're</b><b>going to get into</b><b>and find out more</b><b>about today.</b><b>My first guest here</b><b>who we're going to</b><b>hear from as a speaker</b><b>giving a</b><b>presentation later too</b><b>is Matt Rain from</b><b>Digital Urban. Digital</b><b>Urban is really</b><b>interesting because</b><b>it's getting into</b><b>that space around how</b><b>do you engage and</b><b>communicate with</b><b>people in a way that</b><b>perhaps younger people</b><b>are becoming more and</b><b>more accustomed to</b><b>because it uses</b><b>computers but also in</b><b>the sense of gaming</b><b>and the metaverse and</b><b>virtual reality and so</b><b>really interested to</b><b>hear more</b><b>about that Matt.</b><b>Welcome and maybe you</b><b>could tell us a bit</b><b>about yourself and how</b><b>you got into</b><b>this in the first</b><b>place. Yeah great</b><b>thanks Max, thanks for</b><b>having me. My</b><b>background really is</b><b>public</b><b>sector. I worked</b><b>for the first 10 years</b><b>of my career in police</b><b>agencies, most</b><b>recently the National</b><b>Crime Agency</b><b>so my background is</b><b>about human behavior.</b><b>At that time it was</b><b>about understanding,</b><b>analyzing and</b><b>interpreting offender</b><b>behavior. It's</b><b>something that's kind</b><b>of a common theme</b><b>that's always run</b><b>through my career</b><b>analyzing,</b><b>interpreting,</b><b>understanding and then</b><b>trying to change human</b><b>behavior because from</b><b>that I moved into</b><b>local authorities and</b><b>I mainly dealt with</b><b>learning and</b><b>development,</b><b>organizational</b><b>development so</b><b>training people in</b><b>terms of leadership</b><b>and other skills as</b><b>well and then I sort</b><b>of moved into regen</b><b>while I was in the</b><b>local authorities and</b><b>I used my background</b><b>in engagement and</b><b>human behavior and</b><b>understanding that to</b><b>try and help and bring</b><b>that to a regen</b><b>situation and now I'm</b><b>just really trying to</b><b>interested and trying</b><b>to while I'm</b><b>still trying</b><b>to analyze and</b><b>interpret human</b><b>behavior now my role</b><b>really is about</b><b>influencing</b><b>it as well.</b><b>Brilliant and I did</b><b>see you had a bit of a</b><b>showcase at the</b><b>National Urban Design</b><b>Conference</b><b>recently and there was</b><b>a real buzz around</b><b>that and you had your</b><b>VR goggles and</b><b>people were able</b><b>to experience</b><b>different types of</b><b>environments, how they</b><b>might be in the</b><b>future. Can</b><b>you tell us</b><b>when you're engaging</b><b>people in that way,</b><b>what's the big</b><b>difference between</b><b>doing that or the more</b><b>conventional sort of</b><b>exhibition boards in a</b><b>room, in a town hall</b><b>or you know yeah,</b><b>interesting to know</b><b>what you think the</b><b>difference is. Well I</b><b>think there's a</b><b>massive difference,</b><b>I think there's a</b><b>number of factors that</b><b>I think these digital</b><b>tools are really</b><b>beneficial when</b><b>it comes to community</b><b>engagement. I think</b><b>the first one is</b><b>inclusivity, it makes</b><b>information</b><b>much easier to</b><b>understand, it's much</b><b>more visual the tools</b><b>that you that we use,</b><b>it's a virtual</b><b>reality, we have a</b><b>video game version</b><b>often of proposals</b><b>that we have, we have</b><b>an interactive</b><b>touch table and we</b><b>know that the average</b><b>reading age for</b><b>example in England is</b><b>between that of an</b><b>11 and 14 year old,</b><b>the NHS tailors their</b><b>communication to that</b><b>of a nine year</b><b>old audience.</b><b>What I find</b><b>frustrating I think</b><b>from maybe local</b><b>authorities and</b><b>planning in general is</b><b>the overly</b><b>complex technical</b><b>nature of some of the</b><b>concepts that you're</b><b>trying to communicate</b><b>to the general</b><b>public and if you're a</b><b>member of the public</b><b>with a with a national</b><b>average</b><b>reading age or lower</b><b>or your English isn't</b><b>your first language or</b><b>you find it difficult</b><b>to you have a</b><b>different learning</b><b>style to maybe some</b><b>people who gather</b><b>their information from</b><b>reading as</b><b>many people do,</b><b>you can often find the</b><b>consultation process</b><b>quite exclusive so our</b><b>tools are</b><b>really good at</b><b>including people,</b><b>getting people in,</b><b>actually having fun a</b><b>public consultation</b><b>event as well</b><b>which I think has its</b><b>merits too, so it</b><b>really makes a</b><b>difference in terms of</b><b>inclusivity,</b><b>it makes a huge</b><b>difference in terms of</b><b>people's understanding</b><b>of schemes, if</b><b>you can immerse</b><b>somebody within the</b><b>proposals then they're</b><b>much more likely to</b><b>understand what they</b><b>mean for them</b><b>so we often find that</b><b>people as I'm sure</b><b>everybody does are a</b><b>bit nervous when it</b><b>comes to change or</b><b>things that are new,</b><b>we hear the term nimby</b><b>banded around quite a</b><b>lot but actually what</b><b>we find is</b><b>that if we can immerse</b><b>them within the future</b><b>of their place then</b><b>they're much</b><b>more likely to</b><b>understand the</b><b>reasoning behind why</b><b>things are done and</b><b>actually understand</b><b>what that future place</b><b>will look like and</b><b>they also often talk</b><b>about how things felt</b><b>as well, how did it</b><b>feel to them and</b><b>we can enhance how it</b><b>feels with staging so</b><b>we did a magic carpet</b><b>ride for Folkestone</b><b>where we had a</b><b>fan going which gave</b><b>the experience as</b><b>though they were</b><b>flying through the</b><b>air, we've</b><b>worked with the</b><b>RHS where we played</b><b>with scent and buzzing</b><b>sounds and bees to try</b><b>and really transport</b><b>people into</b><b>the place or the</b><b>proposals that they're</b><b>seeing and we can find</b><b>that's really</b><b>impactful in terms</b><b>of their understanding</b><b>but also in terms of</b><b>their behaviour as</b><b>well, if people can</b><b>make those</b><b>emotional connections</b><b>to future places</b><b>they're much more</b><b>likely to understand</b><b>them and maybe</b><b>want to go back to</b><b>them as well so when</b><b>people come off of our</b><b>experiences if</b><b>there are good</b><b>developments out there</b><b>they're often more</b><b>supportive of them,</b><b>they may have come in</b><b>beforehand</b><b>not being very</b><b>supportive of them but</b><b>we find that we can</b><b>change their mind and</b><b>in the same token if</b><b>there's a really</b><b>shoddy development</b><b>there it's really</b><b>clear to see that from</b><b>the outset, you stick</b><b>it in a virtual</b><b>reality or a video</b><b>game it's really clear</b><b>to see the the rubbish</b><b>design out there so</b><b>we're giving benefit</b><b>to good proposals</b><b>because we're letting</b><b>people see them in</b><b>their true light</b><b>but we're also shining</b><b>a light on those those</b><b>bad ones as well which</b><b>I think as you know an</b><b>urban design</b><b>professional I think</b><b>you and many others</b><b>listening will be</b><b>pleased to hear.</b><b>That's absolutely</b><b>fascinating and I'm</b><b>looking forward to</b><b>trying it out not</b><b>least the the magic</b><b>carpet just to take</b><b>that sort of one step</b><b>further because</b><b>listening to what</b><b>you're saying it's</b><b>almost as though the</b><b>more immersive and the</b><b>more realistic an</b><b>experience can be the</b><b>more likely it</b><b>is someone is going to</b><b>have a more meaningful</b><b>response so where does</b><b>that have to</b><b>stop so for</b><b>example in terms of</b><b>different senses you</b><b>know you mentioned</b><b>sound and smell you</b><b>know with with</b><b>climate change people</b><b>are going to have</b><b>experiencing different</b><b>temperatures and</b><b>seeing how much shade</b><b>makes a difference and</b><b>do you think that that</b><b>one day we'll be able</b><b>to be in a</b><b>situation where we</b><b>can experience a</b><b>project you know</b><b>overseas that might be</b><b>you know 50 degrees</b><b>outside and</b><b>and a lot less inside</b><b>or that type of thing.</b><b>Yeah it's not</b><b>something that we've</b><b>thought about yet</b><b>I have now and now</b><b>you've mentioned it</b><b>maybe we could do</b><b>something in the UAE</b><b>in a sauna or</b><b>something and you know</b><b>get to feel helpful</b><b>it's really light but</b><b>yeah we could</b><b>absolutely</b><b>experiment with that I</b><b>think that's a it's</b><b>again one of the many</b><b>uses of the</b><b>tools that we have</b><b>is that they are</b><b>really versatile and</b><b>flexible and that we</b><b>can we're all on our</b><b>next our latest</b><b>project is always our</b><b>best one and we're</b><b>always trying new</b><b>things on our latest</b><b>projects we've</b><b>got a this week in</b><b>fact in Ramsgate in</b><b>Kent we've developed a</b><b>virtual reality</b><b>hovercraft ride</b><b>across the the high</b><b>street and the and the</b><b>harbor area of</b><b>Ramsgate so we're</b><b>always looking to</b><b>develop and innovate</b><b>with our tools and do</b><b>something different</b><b>and capture the</b><b>imagination</b><b>especially bespoke to</b><b>places Ramsgate you</b><b>might know has a</b><b>history of the</b><b>hovercraft</b><b>used to get the cross</b><b>channel hovercraft</b><b>there to France back</b><b>in the 80s</b><b>so we're always</b><b>looking looking for</b><b>that angle I think</b><b>with places to make it</b><b>really relevant</b><b>for the local</b><b>community and the and</b><b>the clients that we</b><b>work with.</b><b>My next guest that we</b><b>have here with us</b><b>today is Tianan from</b><b>Hello Lamp Post</b><b>great name and</b><b>an organization I've</b><b>heard about but I</b><b>don't know a huge</b><b>amount about so I'm</b><b>really interested to</b><b>find out more I know</b><b>you're going to be</b><b>giving a presentation</b><b>this afternoon but can</b><b>you tell us</b><b>you know a bit about</b><b>you and your</b><b>background and and</b><b>about Hello Lamp Post</b><b>and and what that is</b><b>exactly. I'll try and</b><b>do the short version</b><b>my background has been</b><b>mostly</b><b>commercial so started a</b><b>few ventures in the</b><b>past all all</b><b>predominantly focused</b><b>on really software</b><b>businesses but before</b><b>that actually</b><b>coincidentally my</b><b>experience and my</b><b>career started off in</b><b>real estate and</b><b>surveying so</b><b>actually looking back</b><b>it gave me a lot of</b><b>understanding about</b><b>how we as society use</b><b>physical places how we</b><b>interact with them how</b><b>we influence them and</b><b>how we feed</b><b>back about them so</b><b>actually you know</b><b>looking</b><b>retrospectively gave</b><b>me a great grounding</b><b>for founding</b><b>Hello Lamp Post</b><b>and fast forward a</b><b>little bit so founded</b><b>Hello Lamp Post with</b><b>my two</b><b>co-founders in 2018</b><b>and the short story</b><b>really is we provide</b><b>digital assistance for</b><b>any place so that can</b><b>be a basically</b><b>a digital staff member</b><b>for anything from an</b><b>airport a public park</b><b>a shopping</b><b>mall a office</b><b>building a residential</b><b>building whatever that</b><b>might be and for those</b><b>organizations</b><b>and companies</b><b>public or private it</b><b>allows them to extend</b><b>their team so to have</b><b>a digital staff</b><b>member in a home</b><b>in an office building</b><b>in a hospital giving</b><b>people information in</b><b>the moment also</b><b>supporting them but</b><b>also importantly</b><b>gathering their</b><b>feedback gathering</b><b>their sentiment their</b><b>opinions all</b><b>of the time in</b><b>real time and that</b><b>takes the format of a</b><b>chat interface so</b><b>someone will come</b><b>across in that</b><b>place in that specific</b><b>location so whether it</b><b>be a hospital waiting</b><b>room or a</b><b>desk in an office</b><b>building and they'll</b><b>interact using their</b><b>their phone via sms or</b><b>scan the qr</b><b>code and they're</b><b>into a friendly</b><b>digital assistant chat</b><b>so it's really a way</b><b>for to better connect</b><b>people society</b><b>communities audiences</b><b>with the organizations</b><b>that run those places</b><b>okay really</b><b>interesting</b><b>i'm looking</b><b>an image in the</b><b>background of a human</b><b>hand and a robotic</b><b>hand and i'm wondering</b><b>does hulla lamp</b><b>post actually extend</b><b>to having a robot that</b><b>might do that the chat</b><b>box type thing</b><b>or is it always</b><b>through the app and</b><b>the phone uh no plans</b><b>has yet to have</b><b>physical robots but</b><b>that's not to say</b><b>not to say that won't</b><b>happen in the future</b><b>but at the moment yeah</b><b>it's purely</b><b>software so</b><b>we're trying to lower</b><b>the barriers so</b><b>actually there's no</b><b>separate app for a</b><b>user to download</b><b>they just scan the qr</b><b>code or sms a phone</b><b>number so they don't</b><b>even need to have a</b><b>smartphone</b><b>necessarily and if</b><b>they scan the scan the</b><b>qr code it just opens</b><b>up a browser so they</b><b>don't need</b><b>an account or a login</b><b>or a separate app to</b><b>download so we really</b><b>want to lower</b><b>the barriers</b><b>to entry for us people</b><b>using a place to get</b><b>information and</b><b>support but</b><b>also for councils</b><b>or landlords or</b><b>whoever they are not</b><b>only to better support</b><b>more people but</b><b>understand their</b><b>needs better so it so</b><b>if we're talking about</b><b>a built environment</b><b>project and</b><b>it's sort of very</b><b>early days before</b><b>there's a sort of even</b><b>a concept or a scheme</b><b>but you're wanting to</b><b>find out what</b><b>people think about</b><b>that area that place</b><b>the name hullo lamp</b><b>post suggests you</b><b>might even have</b><b>the qr codes up on</b><b>lamp post it yeah and</b><b>and then how does that</b><b>then sort of evolve as</b><b>it might get</b><b>into sort of planning</b><b>construction do you</b><b>stay with the process</b><b>all the way</b><b>through or yeah</b><b>absolutely i mean one</b><b>of our motto is really</b><b>is is meet people</b><b>where they are one of</b><b>the kind of</b><b>early observations</b><b>that we found is</b><b>certainly when it</b><b>comes to engagement</b><b>and gathering</b><b>opinions and</b><b>feedback is it's</b><b>mostly desk based yes</b><b>you have kind of</b><b>in-person events but</b><b>that perhaps only</b><b>meets a small segment</b><b>of of the audience or</b><b>a community so being</b><b>able to meet people</b><b>where they</b><b>are in that place</b><b>that's relevant for</b><b>that consultation or</b><b>or project</b><b>allows you to be</b><b>there every step of</b><b>the way so yeah it</b><b>might be it might be</b><b>signs in a park for</b><b>example or whatever</b><b>that site is that</b><b>location is that</b><b>allows people to</b><b>interact and the</b><b>system can ask</b><b>people questions</b><b>and their opinions</b><b>once it goes into</b><b>construction then you</b><b>know hoardings can go</b><b>up you know we're</b><b>working on a site</b><b>olympia site in</b><b>kensington in in</b><b>london and there's</b><b>signs on</b><b>their holdings</b><b>gathering people's</b><b>sentiment and opinions</b><b>and feedback right</b><b>through to</b><b>operational so once</b><b>something exists you</b><b>know the consultation</b><b>and engagement</b><b>shouldn't stop there</b><b>you know at the</b><b>end of the day you're</b><b>still providing a</b><b>place and a service</b><b>for people you should</b><b>you should listen</b><b>to those end users</b><b>okay and so we're now</b><b>about to kick off the</b><b>formal proceedings and</b><b>we're going</b><b>to start with an open</b><b>mic session we're in</b><b>we're in the seven</b><b>dials club in common</b><b>garden and it's</b><b>probably best known</b><b>for having um comedy</b><b>nights and that's what</b><b>sort of gave</b><b>us the idea of</b><b>following a similar</b><b>type of format where</b><b>anyone can say</b><b>anything about the</b><b>topic and uh no holds</b><b>barred so uh it went</b><b>really well the last</b><b>time we did this let's</b><b>see if we can do it</b><b>again now we're</b><b>talking about a more</b><b>specific topic my name</b><b>is um john littel um</b><b>i'm one of the</b><b>co-founders of</b><b>beater streets um a</b><b>street design</b><b>visualization software</b><b>company i i mean i</b><b>think the potential</b><b>is huge um i mean i i</b><b>also think it's kind</b><b>of a catchall term for</b><b>lots of things</b><b>at the moment</b><b>where we kind of you</b><b>know ai sounds um like</b><b>robots are taken over</b><b>the world</b><b>terminator style</b><b>and what we actually</b><b>mean is kind of</b><b>machine learning in</b><b>some instances and</b><b>actually incremental</b><b>uh tools that really</b><b>support other tools</b><b>and and make them more</b><b>efficient so</b><b>um i mean i'm</b><b>generally quite</b><b>excited about it</b><b>particularly with its</b><b>potential to help us</b><b>with the quite</b><b>mundane task of of um</b><b>sorting through</b><b>responses and and that</b><b>kind of stuff but as</b><b>people have</b><b>talked about earlier</b><b>there are some risks</b><b>associated with that</b><b>in that we</b><b>kind of throw</b><b>the baby out with the</b><b>bath water and and by</b><b>adopting all this</b><b>technology we</b><b>forget about the</b><b>really important part</b><b>of community</b><b>engagement which is</b><b>fundamentally the</b><b>human</b><b>elements around it</b><b>fei cannings london</b><b>barrow at warden</b><b>forest to be honest i</b><b>think we're on the</b><b>start of the journey</b><b>in terms of how we use</b><b>um some of the more</b><b>advanced tools um</b><b>we've certainly</b><b>used platforms</b><b>like um commonplace</b><b>which i think has</b><b>proved really really</b><b>um valuable in</b><b>terms of how we</b><b>reach more diverse</b><b>communities um but</b><b>it's been about making</b><b>sure that we</b><b>um ask the right</b><b>questions um that we</b><b>yeah we target the</b><b>right information and</b><b>we gain that</b><b>feedback in in the</b><b>best possible way to</b><b>inform our decisions</b><b>um so we just had to</b><b>take what a i guess</b><b>quite an informed</b><b>approach to how we do</b><b>that and and then</b><b>making sure that we</b><b>then follow</b><b>through with that</b><b>information and we can</b><b>actually utilize it to</b><b>best effect so my name</b><b>is that you</b><b>and mills i'm the</b><b>co-founder of block</b><b>type we're a</b><b>technology company</b><b>that helps property</b><b>developers and</b><b>planners understand</b><b>how much housing they</b><b>can fit on a site so</b><b>uh and i think</b><b>it's going to</b><b>change everything this</b><b>is more than a tool</b><b>it's the first time</b><b>we're building a</b><b>technology</b><b>that can actually</b><b>generate information</b><b>which is</b><b>indistinguishable from</b><b>from from</b><b>humans right and</b><b>i think uh when we</b><b>have a technology that</b><b>can do that it becomes</b><b>incredibly hard to</b><b>know what is</b><b>real and what isn't</b><b>right information is</b><b>changing everything so</b><b>my name is suresh i'm</b><b>from boyden</b><b>and i recruit c-suite</b><b>individuals into their</b><b>social housing sector</b><b>my concern is if if a</b><b>ai is a learning tool</b><b>it's the data that's</b><b>going into it which is</b><b>giving us</b><b>answers back for what</b><b>we're looking for but</b><b>if the data isn't</b><b>there from segments of</b><b>society are we or will</b><b>it therefore</b><b>leave out certain</b><b>aspects and and give</b><b>us answers that don't</b><b>cover everybody and</b><b>therefore are we</b><b>really representing</b><b>society and those in</b><b>in particularly</b><b>disadvantaged areas</b><b>correctly or</b><b>fairly and it's and</b><b>it's such a powerful</b><b>thing i think uh</b><b>another one of the</b><b>members here talked</b><b>about how it can it</b><b>can create things</b><b>rather than react</b><b>which is even scarier</b><b>because what</b><b>what are you saying</b><b>then you can create or</b><b>fabricate a voice</b><b>which hasn't</b><b>necessarily</b><b>engaged you think you</b><b>have a thought process</b><b>or it can create a</b><b>thought process</b><b>around coming up</b><b>with a an essence of</b><b>what would be said by</b><b>those individuals and</b><b>give you that</b><b>narrative so even if</b><b>they haven't engaged</b><b>you're trying to</b><b>create the narrative</b><b>to engage with that</b><b>again is quite scary</b><b>and i guess for</b><b>somebody who's a</b><b>little bit maybe i'm</b><b>not in tune with it</b><b>enough to understand</b><b>that the the power for</b><b>me was always the</b><b>personal relationship</b><b>is this going to allow</b><b>us to just get</b><b>to more people that's</b><b>all it is and um yeah</b><b>so it's been a</b><b>fascinating</b><b>conversation so far</b><b>okay well that was a</b><b>fantastic uh open mic</b><b>session so many</b><b>interesting viewpoints</b><b>and experiences from</b><b>from a really diverse</b><b>group um coming at it</b><b>from all different</b><b>types of angles so for</b><b>me some of</b><b>the really most</b><b>important takeaways</b><b>were that ai is</b><b>changing rapidly and</b><b>it's now used by most</b><b>people on a daily</b><b>basis ai tools can</b><b>definitely help</b><b>capture feedback from</b><b>group discussions in a</b><b>very helpful way but</b><b>human experience of</b><b>those discussions is</b><b>also essential</b><b>to gain that sort</b><b>of full picture the</b><b>full insight there's</b><b>obviously uh risks</b><b>associated with ai</b><b>that has a uh you know</b><b>does cause concern and</b><b>the things like bias</b><b>or or the ability to</b><b>create</b><b>information that's</b><b>indistinguishable from</b><b>what a human might</b><b>create and also i</b><b>think what really came</b><b>across from that</b><b>session was that</b><b>there's no silver</b><b>bullet with ai and</b><b>that the effectiveness</b><b>of the tools really</b><b>depends on on how they</b><b>are used we've heard</b><b>from uh two of our</b><b>speakers who have</b><b>given presentations</b><b>about their particular</b><b>sort of platforms and</b><b>now we're going to</b><b>hear from others</b><b>including ollie</b><b>ollie is the director</b><b>founder of ECF which</b><b>stands for engage</b><b>communicate facilitate</b><b>and they've</b><b>been doing that on</b><b>projects and campaigns</b><b>really globally in in</b><b>uh in london but also</b><b>uh and and</b><b>the rest of the uk but</b><b>also in sydney and</b><b>australia and i think</b><b>it's really</b><b>interesting</b><b>to hear from</b><b>ollie about their</b><b>experience of how</b><b>things have changed</b><b>and how they're using</b><b>these different</b><b>platforms some of whom</b><b>we've heard from</b><b>already but also</b><b>others like for</b><b>example wild streets</b><b>that are very close to</b><b>my heart as a</b><b>augmented reality app</b><b>that also has a lot of</b><b>data around</b><b>ecosystem services so</b><b>people can see and</b><b>imagine what their</b><b>urban spaces would</b><b>look like with more</b><b>greenery trees and</b><b>plants and then</b><b>understand what impact</b><b>that's having in terms</b><b>of biodiversity air</b><b>quality flood risk and</b><b>so on so let's hear</b><b>from ollie now hello</b><b>everybody ollie</b><b>verdeet from ECF</b><b>here there's a whole</b><b>suite of different</b><b>platforms that are out</b><b>there some of which</b><b>we've worked with</b><b>and some of which we</b><b>haven't when i started</b><b>out doing community</b><b>engagement</b><b>about 15 years ago</b><b>none of this stuff</b><b>existed really so to</b><b>see it develop over</b><b>time has been it's</b><b>been quite</b><b>impressive hello</b><b>lamppost we've done</b><b>some exciting work</b><b>with them both in</b><b>london and um</b><b>in australia</b><b>around using their</b><b>humanistic chatbot to</b><b>facilitate</b><b>conversations in the</b><b>public realm</b><b>and then i know that</b><b>was streets no max has</b><b>had some involvement</b><b>with them they're</b><b>doing some</b><b>really exciting stuff</b><b>around augmented</b><b>reality virtual</b><b>reality particularly</b><b>around public realm</b><b>improvements and we're</b><b>really excited to see</b><b>how that develops and</b><b>i i think these types</b><b>of initiatives</b><b>really do help to</b><b>provide the community</b><b>with mechanisms</b><b>through</b><b>which to actually</b><b>feedback in it what i</b><b>call a low friction</b><b>way so there are time</b><b>poor individuals out</b><b>there in a</b><b>community that don't</b><b>want to turn up to a</b><b>public exhibition</b><b>don't want to come to</b><b>workshops but</b><b>they will engage with</b><b>these types of</b><b>platforms the digital</b><b>urban team they're</b><b>doing some really</b><b>exciting stuff around</b><b>virtual reality and</b><b>augmented reality and</b><b>i think this has got</b><b>the power to really</b><b>transform that actual</b><b>physical engagement</b><b>experience that we're</b><b>immersed in day</b><b>to day so those</b><b>drop-in events those</b><b>public exhibitions</b><b>those workshops can be</b><b>really enhanced</b><b>by good artesian</b><b>intelligence good</b><b>virtual reality</b><b>products and i think</b><b>this is uh there's</b><b>going to be lots of</b><b>this sort of stuff</b><b>coming forward over</b><b>over the years</b><b>and in terms of</b><b>the quantitative and</b><b>qualitative analysis</b><b>one of the problems</b><b>we've found over the</b><b>years is that</b><b>thematically coding or</b><b>coding up data for</b><b>sentiment is a very</b><b>time</b><b>consuming operation</b><b>at the moment and</b><b>there are now a couple</b><b>of tools that have</b><b>come online that will</b><b>help you do that</b><b>we've used citizens</b><b>lab we haven't used</b><b>future fox yet but</b><b>we've spoken to the</b><b>team there and</b><b>you know the promise</b><b>here is that 80 to 90</b><b>percent of some of</b><b>that coding</b><b>and analysis</b><b>particularly on the</b><b>qualitative side that</b><b>we're doing at the</b><b>moment could be done</b><b>by effectively</b><b>machinery and that</b><b>would really free you</b><b>up to do more work to</b><b>get people</b><b>participating in into</b><b>the process and that's</b><b>it that's uh hopefully</b><b>a little bit of a</b><b>whistle-stop tour on</b><b>some of the</b><b>things that we're</b><b>trying to consider</b><b>around artificial</b><b>intelligence we're</b><b>really excited</b><b>this will be a great</b><b>conversation today i'm</b><b>looking forward to</b><b>hearing how it</b><b>goes and what</b><b>the outcomes are and</b><b>enjoy the afternoon</b><b>thank you very much i</b><b>think what for me</b><b>could be a really</b><b>interesting case study</b><b>is the work that um</b><b>tanisha rafudin has</b><b>been doing with</b><b>another one of our</b><b>members roomie bows</b><b>it's a case study in</b><b>um what success looks</b><b>like when you do</b><b>community engagement</b><b>properly but it also</b><b>really started to use</b><b>technology and ai in</b><b>quite an</b><b>innovative way</b><b>welcome tanisha you're</b><b>here today to talk</b><b>quite specifically</b><b>about one of the</b><b>projects you worked</b><b>on with another one of</b><b>our members roomie</b><b>bows and that was in</b><b>neeston in and it was</b><b>working with</b><b>brent council and just</b><b>interested to know a</b><b>bit more about that</b><b>project and how they</b><b>started to</b><b>maybe adopt some more</b><b>progressive ideas</b><b>around the use of</b><b>technology because i</b><b>know it's always</b><b>difficult for local</b><b>authorities to to take</b><b>on sort of new new</b><b>innovation without it</b><b>being fully tried</b><b>and tested say so yeah</b><b>tell us a bit more</b><b>about that absolutely</b><b>so as part of their</b><b>application</b><b>to the mayor of</b><b>london's civic</b><b>partnership program</b><b>run by the gla brent</b><b>council</b><b>commissioned us as</b><b>the design team made</b><b>up of santa spenton</b><b>architects roomie bows</b><b>and where pathways</b><b>meet and concept</b><b>culture to develop a</b><b>strategic vision and</b><b>action plan to set out</b><b>a roadmap to</b><b>transform neeston</b><b>town center into a</b><b>thriving neighborhood</b><b>through meaningful</b><b>engagement with the</b><b>local community</b><b>so the council brief</b><b>was very clear that we</b><b>had to reach as many</b><b>voices as</b><b>possible and they were</b><b>particularly keen to</b><b>reach the typically</b><b>unheard voices but the</b><b>key thing i'd like to</b><b>outline here</b><b>were the project</b><b>constraints we had a</b><b>very tight time scale</b><b>and a very tight</b><b>budget so we were</b><b>commissioned towards</b><b>the end of december of</b><b>2023 to deliver this</b><b>action plan by the</b><b>beginning of</b><b>april 2024 and so the</b><b>majority of the</b><b>community engagement</b><b>activities were run</b><b>between february</b><b>and march and as most</b><b>people will know</b><b>that's not enough time</b><b>to run meaningful</b><b>community engagement</b><b>and so we did use</b><b>digital tools we did</b><b>use technology we did</b><b>use um ai and</b><b>interestingly</b><b>enough it was brent</b><b>council's own have</b><b>your say platform and</b><b>we were very</b><b>fortunate to have a</b><b>council officer rea</b><b>regenitor officer</b><b>bruna at the time who</b><b>was very much all</b><b>about using technology</b><b>using ai uh using the</b><b>right digital tools to</b><b>you know bring the</b><b>community along</b><b>with us in the</b><b>journey but obviously</b><b>we were limited with</b><b>budget in distance and</b><b>so we were limited and</b><b>so we ended</b><b>up using brent</b><b>council's own platform</b><b>and exploring more</b><b>advanced tools but</b><b>having said that the</b><b>platform did the job</b><b>we were able to launch</b><b>a digital engagement</b><b>campaign</b><b>asking the community</b><b>about their priorities</b><b>and their aspirations</b><b>for the town's town</b><b>center and what the ai</b><b>tool allowed</b><b>us to do was sentiment</b><b>analysis very quickly</b><b>and it produced very</b><b>clever graphics and</b><b>reports and</b><b>graphs and word clouds</b><b>which we could then</b><b>input into the</b><b>engagement report and</b><b>again we were</b><b>running to very very</b><b>tight timescale the</b><b>design team you know</b><b>long hours working</b><b>together to</b><b>produce this massive</b><b>report so it helped a</b><b>lot in terms of</b><b>efficiency and</b><b>delivering the final</b><b>output and the final</b><b>output was an</b><b>engagement and</b><b>co-design report which</b><b>fed into the</b><b>action plan</b><b>and it was all about</b><b>and the vision was all</b><b>about delivering a</b><b>fairer safer</b><b>greener healthier</b><b>connected and more</b><b>diverse neisden and</b><b>i'm pleased to share</b><b>that the bid was</b><b>ultimately successful</b><b>and secured 3.1</b><b>million of funding for</b><b>brent council for a</b><b>substantial level of</b><b>improvement</b><b>for neisden town</b><b>center wow that's a</b><b>real success story and</b><b>i know how hard it is</b><b>to to win those</b><b>bids for government</b><b>funding that are so so</b><b>in demand so tell me</b><b>you know when</b><b>you did that</b><b>engagement and you you</b><b>you asked people about</b><b>their sentiments</b><b>that's that's really</b><b>interesting</b><b>so it was more about</b><b>how they felt about</b><b>the place or</b><b>particular ideas or</b><b>what really</b><b>needed to change</b><b>and what didn't um can</b><b>you think of anything</b><b>specifically that came</b><b>up that maybe was</b><b>uh interesting that</b><b>you hadn't thought of</b><b>that came through that</b><b>process that</b><b>ended up being</b><b>part of the bid or no</b><b>sadly no i think the</b><b>sentiment analysis</b><b>kind of</b><b>reflected what we</b><b>already understood</b><b>while we met with well</b><b>through the in-person</b><b>engagements as well um</b><b>the residents feel</b><b>neglected they feel</b><b>that the council</b><b>hasn't paid</b><b>attention to them</b><b>over other surrounding</b><b>areas and other</b><b>surrounding town</b><b>centers and you could</b><b>feel that so</b><b>i wouldn't say that it</b><b>it shared anything new</b><b>but i think it enabled</b><b>people to</b><b>be honest and</b><b>upfront about what</b><b>they felt sadly and</b><b>feel like they've had</b><b>a chance and then feel</b><b>like they've</b><b>had a chance to say so</b><b>i think that was</b><b>important to empower</b><b>people with the right</b><b>tools and give</b><b>them that voice and</b><b>feel like you know</b><b>they've had an</b><b>opportunity to to say</b><b>something okay and</b><b>that is valuable in</b><b>itself isn't it and</b><b>and you know the thing</b><b>about using digital</b><b>and technology</b><b>is it enables you to</b><b>do a lot more with a</b><b>lot less human</b><b>resource and that is</b><b>the big issue for</b><b>councils at the moment</b><b>isn't it where they</b><b>are very strapped for</b><b>cash but also they</b><b>just don't</b><b>have this the staff</b><b>other than for sort of</b><b>emergency services and</b><b>and uh you know social</b><b>care and education and</b><b>so on so did you think</b><b>did you find that was</b><b>a a key</b><b>part of it that</b><b>technology enabled you</b><b>to do i suppose more</b><b>with less yes that's</b><b>definitely one thing i</b><b>would like</b><b>to highlight given the</b><b>fact that we had to</b><b>deliver this project</b><b>within two</b><b>months uh time</b><b>it made things much</b><b>easier much quicker</b><b>and we were able to</b><b>float the the campaign</b><b>for a couple</b><b>of weeks um with more</b><b>time and more budget</b><b>uh what i would have</b><b>liked to have done is</b><b>conduct more</b><b>far-reaching social</b><b>media campaigns</b><b>perhaps using other</b><b>platforms like tick</b><b>tock as an example to</b><b>reach the younger</b><b>voices the next</b><b>generation gen z gen</b><b>alpha whose voices are</b><b>also equally valuable</b><b>and um around the</b><b>campaign for a couple</b><b>of more weeks and</b><b>again that's wishful</b><b>thinking maybe in</b><b>this case but</b><b>hopefully next time</b><b>that's definitely a</b><b>lesson uh the team</b><b>will take</b><b>forward to have to</b><b>to to push for more</b><b>time uh to deliver</b><b>meaningful engagement</b><b>and gather that</b><b>sentiment analysis and</b><b>empower people to have</b><b>um that voice and</b><b>certainly going back</b><b>to your question about</b><b>whether we</b><b>uncover something new</b><b>i think there are a</b><b>lot of ideas</b><b>definitely from uh the</b><b>youth engagement that</b><b>we probably wouldn't</b><b>have thought about but</b><b>again because we're</b><b>you know we're</b><b>different it's often</b><b>i suppose about not</b><b>not necessarily the</b><b>message but who is</b><b>delivering the message</b><b>and i think the</b><b>interesting thing</b><b>about you know</b><b>platforms like tick</b><b>tock is there are</b><b>these influences that</b><b>have huge followings</b><b>that people really do</b><b>listen to who are</b><b>increasingly</b><b>interested in</b><b>their built</b><b>environment and feel</b><b>like they are</b><b>empowered to change</b><b>that or</b><b>criticize it i saw</b><b>a brilliant video</b><b>recently of a young a</b><b>young resident in</b><b>hackney who was just</b><b>let's just say</b><b>had a very um jaded</b><b>view of the new old</b><b>street roundabout uh</b><b>improvements</b><b>after all the money</b><b>and time that had been</b><b>spent and it was</b><b>really powerful much</b><b>more so i think than</b><b>than uh you</b><b>know watching an item</b><b>on the news you know i</b><b>i would i would agree</b><b>and you know the there</b><b>is a whole</b><b>generation out there</b><b>particularly gens at</b><b>uh gen alpha maybe the</b><b>younger millilians as</b><b>well who are</b><b>uh you know and</b><b>shamedly open on</b><b>social media and you</b><b>will get unfiltered uh</b><b>unrestricted</b><b>comments and real</b><b>feedback and genuine</b><b>feedback if you care</b><b>to listen i think the</b><b>other element</b><b>is listening so</b><b>there's there are the</b><b>tools there's there is</b><b>the tech there you</b><b>know ai is</b><b>getting more</b><b>and mature as we speak</b><b>but on the other end</b><b>is are you willing to</b><b>listen you</b><b>know as the as the</b><b>council or as a</b><b>developer or as</b><b>someone who you know</b><b>who owns and manages</b><b>these assets</b><b>how much are</b><b>you willing to listen</b><b>and take on board the</b><b>feedback is also a</b><b>part of the</b><b>conversation</b><b>well thank you so much</b><b>tanisha that's an</b><b>absolutely brilliant</b><b>case study and uh lots</b><b>lots of food for</b><b>thought for me the</b><b>most important</b><b>takeaways from those</b><b>presentations were</b><b>that you know ai tools</b><b>are clearly uh</b><b>incredibly helpful</b><b>when it comes to</b><b>things like repetitive</b><b>or or time consuming</b><b>tasks and critically</b><b>that that can free up</b><b>sort of human</b><b>resourcing which</b><b>doesn't mean</b><b>that humans</b><b>are no longer needed</b><b>but they're just</b><b>needed to do different</b><b>types of things that</b><b>can add value i</b><b>think we're clearly</b><b>we're still in in</b><b>relatively early</b><b>stages of ai so there</b><b>there is still a lot</b><b>of skepticism out</b><b>there but the sort of</b><b>context setting and</b><b>transparency can</b><b>definitely help build</b><b>trust in the use of it</b><b>um there's obviously a</b><b>concern that the</b><b>commercial</b><b>drive of ai is</b><b>outpacing the ethics</b><b>something that there's</b><b>a long history of um</b><b>science and</b><b>technology doing</b><b>over over the decades</b><b>and centuries but um</b><b>what's always come</b><b>into play is about</b><b>government</b><b>intervention and</b><b>through legislation</b><b>and and i think we're</b><b>seeing more</b><b>of that now</b><b>in terms of creating</b><b>those conditions and a</b><b>sort of the regulatory</b><b>landscape um</b><b>it's it's obviously</b><b>important to everyone</b><b>that humans retain</b><b>oversight and other</b><b>sort of final decision</b><b>making power if</b><b>you like and there has</b><b>to be human points of</b><b>contact within the</b><b>community</b><b>otherwise it's just</b><b>too abstracted and</b><b>you're not getting the</b><b>full um the full</b><b>picture in a</b><b>meaningful</b><b>way i think that</b><b>one of the interesting</b><b>things that came up is</b><b>that the reach of</b><b>community engagement</b><b>can definitely</b><b>be extended whether</b><b>that's through social</b><b>media you know</b><b>targeted ad campaigns</b><b>but also being</b><b>able to go out to</b><b>people and using these</b><b>types of innovative</b><b>engagement methods</b><b>that are more</b><b>appealing and more</b><b>commonplace um excuse</b><b>the pun for younger</b><b>people or people who</b><b>have english as</b><b>a second language you</b><b>know it's about having</b><b>a variety of tools at</b><b>your</b><b>disposal to it makes</b><b>sure that the largest</b><b>number of people can</b><b>contribute to their</b><b>places and how</b><b>they're developed</b><b>so we're going to open</b><b>up to a panel</b><b>discussion now and</b><b>invite the audience to</b><b>ask questions and open</b><b>it up to a wider</b><b>conversation and in</b><b>particular i think</b><b>it will be interesting</b><b>to have some snippets</b><b>from the panel members</b><b>the ones we haven't</b><b>heard from</b><b>so far on the podcast</b><b>um like Nicola from</b><b>Grosvenor who are</b><b>really embracing</b><b>innovation within</b><b>engaging with their</b><b>residents and the</b><b>people that that</b><b>experience and use</b><b>their places</b><b>and also from</b><b>Dorian who is from</b><b>commonplace another</b><b>member of the LDN</b><b>collective who really</b><b>are transformational</b><b>when when when their</b><b>platform is used i</b><b>often say you can</b><b>really tell the</b><b>difference between</b><b>a project that's used</b><b>a commonplace platform</b><b>and one that hasn't</b><b>and so so let's</b><b>hear from them</b><b>about what they think</b><b>are the important</b><b>issues Dorian O'Neill</b><b>from commonplace i</b><b>think the main</b><b>kind of benefits as i</b><b>mentioned in my kind</b><b>of talk apart from the</b><b>obvious things around</b><b>savings and</b><b>efficiencies and</b><b>helping with the back</b><b>end processes and the</b><b>admin and the</b><b>laborious tasks</b><b>it's just encouraging</b><b>councils or developers</b><b>to kind of go out to</b><b>more people and i</b><b>think at the</b><b>moment particularly</b><b>for planning teams</b><b>that are</b><b>under-resourced you</b><b>know they have they</b><b>don't have</b><b>much staff so i think</b><b>actually by using</b><b>technology and AI and</b><b>taking some of that</b><b>kind of work off</b><b>them it then enables</b><b>them to do some of the</b><b>really meaningful</b><b>engagements so getting</b><b>out there face</b><b>to face and kind of</b><b>having conversations</b><b>with people yeah in</b><b>that in that way yeah</b><b>commonplace</b><b>developed an AI</b><b>solution with central</b><b>government and three</b><b>different</b><b>councils to help with</b><b>efficiencies and</b><b>savings particularly</b><b>for local government</b><b>so the AI that we've</b><b>developed helps</b><b>analyze a lot of free</b><b>text comments as well</b><b>as kind of summarizing</b><b>questions and</b><b>we use voice</b><b>capture as well as</b><b>we're developing a new</b><b>chat gpt kind of style</b><b>bot where people can</b><b>interrogate</b><b>their consultations so</b><b>in a nutshell it's</b><b>just about helping our</b><b>customers to process</b><b>and analyze</b><b>that information more</b><b>effectively so for</b><b>example looking at a</b><b>long text comment kind</b><b>of being able</b><b>to identify sentiments</b><b>and topics and being</b><b>able to kind of kind</b><b>of quickly identify</b><b>patterns in</b><b>the community what's</b><b>important to people</b><b>what are the key</b><b>talking points and</b><b>being able to quickly</b><b>report that and</b><b>visually share that</b><b>information with key</b><b>stakeholders and</b><b>communities to help</b><b>build trust and</b><b>transparency that</b><b>they're involved in</b><b>that decision making</b><b>and that</b><b>their thoughts</b><b>count i think it will</b><b>really help kind of</b><b>planning professionals</b><b>focus on ultimately</b><b>what they're paid to</b><b>do and their stuff</b><b>that they've done</b><b>their degree on and i</b><b>think hopefully</b><b>it will take a lot of</b><b>stress away from that</b><b>profession because at</b><b>the moment</b><b>i think kind</b><b>i think kind of</b><b>of speaking more</b><b>widely i think local</b><b>government and</b><b>planning teams they</b><b>struggle with</b><b>recruitment</b><b>recruitment and to</b><b>and to attract kind of</b><b>younger people and i</b><b>think maybe some of</b><b>that is a lot</b><b>of that laborious</b><b>laborious tasks that i</b><b>tasks that i just</b><b>mentioned you know the</b><b>admin style stuff that</b><b>no one likes so</b><b>actually being</b><b>able to kind of</b><b>promote the sector in</b><b>a more kind of modern</b><b>innovative way that's</b><b>using tech and AI</b><b>and AI i think</b><b>i think will actually</b><b>attract more people</b><b>into it which i think</b><b>is needed. Hi my</b><b>name's Nicola</b><b>is Nicola</b><b>Rotrol and i lead on</b><b>community engagement</b><b>and insights for</b><b>Grosvenor. Grosvenor</b><b>is a property</b><b>company that has over</b><b>300 years of</b><b>experience in making</b><b>and managing places</b><b>and we wear many</b><b>different hats</b><b>investor, developer,</b><b>partner landlords and</b><b>partner, landlords and</b><b>part of my role is</b><b>making sure</b><b>that people in our</b><b>business understand</b><b>what they need to do</b><b>to engage the varied</b><b>but wonderful</b><b>communities in the</b><b>places that we work</b><b>properly. It's fair to</b><b>say that we're very</b><b>early in our AI</b><b>our AI journey but</b><b>journey but some of</b><b>the use cases that</b><b>we're currently</b><b>exploring is using AI</b><b>to code and</b><b>analyze qualitative</b><b>responses in free tech</b><b>surveys for example</b><b>and also considering</b><b>how it might make</b><b>our processes around</b><b>comms and engagement</b><b>with communities more</b><b>effective to</b><b>free up our time</b><b>so that we can focus</b><b>on much more important</b><b>things. I think a good</b><b>outcome from</b><b>the use of AI at</b><b>from the use of AI at</b><b>Grosvenor is</b><b>definitely making sure</b><b>that our quality of</b><b>engagement is</b><b>not suffering</b><b>suffering but that</b><b>but that we're able to</b><b>make our processes</b><b>much more efficient.</b><b>Wow so some incredible</b><b>Wow so some</b><b>incredible insights</b><b>insights there and</b><b>there and it's been</b><b>such a brilliant day</b><b>today and so good to</b><b>get everyone together.</b><b>together i hope this</b><b>I hope this</b><b>experiment with a live</b><b>podcast with multiple</b><b>voices comes out as</b><b>well as the event</b><b>itself did and</b><b>and and i hope it</b><b>and I hope it</b><b>encourages more people</b><b>to come along to our</b><b>future events. We're</b><b>very open to</b><b>suggestions for topics</b><b>and themes. I think in</b><b>the new year we are</b><b>likely to look</b><b>at new towns,</b><b>to look at new towns</b><b>new settlements</b><b>new settlements.</b><b>new settlements</b><b>clearly the</b><b>Clearly this</b><b>government's drive to</b><b>build one and a half</b><b>million homes over the</b><b>next five years is</b><b>going to need support</b><b>from everybody to help</b><b>achieve that</b><b>critical mission</b><b>mission so so that's</b><b>so that's one</b><b>important topic but</b><b>please do let us know</b><b>any others and you can</b><b>keep up with</b><b>with the ldn</b><b>the LDN Collective and</b><b>find out more about</b><b>different projects and</b><b>initiatives by signing</b><b>up to our newsletter</b><b>on the website or</b><b>following us on</b><b>various social media</b><b>platforms. So I just</b><b>want to say to</b><b>everyone that's</b><b>listening, everyone</b><b>that's listened to the</b><b>various sort</b><b>of podcasts</b><b>that we've done this</b><b>year, the second</b><b>series, to have a</b><b>brilliant and</b><b>enjoyable</b><b>festive break and</b><b>break and look forward</b><b>look forward to</b><b>re-engaging with you</b><b>all in the new year.</b>

People on this episode